Saying the winners of the 2021 AN Better of Design Awards
The grand opening of the Amant Art Campus in Bushwick, Brooklyn (the 2021 AN Best of Design Awards’ Project of the Year) took place on an idyllic Saturday in July. The sun was out but the air, vibrating in the mid-70s, was mild for summer in New York City. There would be a smattering of rain showers later that evening but as the party ramped up, the light was falling across Grand Street in such a way as to lend even that snaggletoothed stretch of auto repair shops, storage facilities, and working-class rowhouses an aura of glamor. This place, intensely gentrified despite its broken-down appearance, still isn’t where one might expect to find award-winning architectural design. But there, hidden behind a subdued facade that could just as easily be the front of a poultry plant, is to be found an essay on spatial and programmatic richness, the deft handling of humble materials, and effective, meaningful formal exploration.
Surprising discoveries such as Amant are a large part of what makes AN’s awards program so rewarding to produce and share with our audience. Here is a statement on the diverse and often unexpected realms where great architecture, great designers, and great products are appearing, across the North American continent and beyond. And this year represents an even richer portfolio of surprises with the addition of our Best of Practice Awards, in which our jury evaluated design firms from across the AEC spectrum on everything from quality of work to employee work/life balance.
Additional highlights for me include The Shelter Project, a resource-packed wooden bus stop featuring a solar-powered charging station, rainwater cistern, and community message board, and the student speculative project Area 10 that locates a museum and visitor center in the bottom of a giant crater made by nuclear bomb testing in the Nevada Desert, showing a way other than depression and anxiety to engage with the more terrifying aspects of the Anthropocene. To learn more about all the winners, pick up a copy of the Best of Design magazine, out now. —Aaron Seward
JURY
Germane Barnes
Director
Studio Barnes
Anda French
Co-founder
French2D
Wonne Ickx
Partner
PRODUCTORA
Carol Ross Barney
Design Principal and Founder
Ross Barney Architects
Thomas Phifer
Founder
Thomas Phifer and Partners
PROJECT OF THE YEAR
“The Amant Art Campus is a place where contemporary art and discourse live. It demanded a strong architecture, abstract in its context and cloaked with direct materials that have a sense of permanence. The poetry of the facades marks the passage of time each day with a treasury of shadows and light.”
PUBLIC
Robertson Recreation Center
“This rec center has real charm and does real work. The undulating walls and roof squeeze the program onto a tight sight while maintaining heritage trees and opening clerestories on the interior, allowing lots of daylight into the basketball court.”
Roxbury Branch of the Boston Public Library Renovation
SOCIAL IMPACT
“Wouldn’t it be great if our urban furniture provided real necessities as opposed to saturating us with advertisements? Here’s a bus shelter that collects rainwater for irrigating plants, harvests solar energy for a charging station, and includes a community bulletin board and pantry in addition to furnishing shade and seating.”
East Clarke Place Senior Residence
Willie Woo Woo Wong Chinese Playground and Clubhouse
Leimert Park Community Fridge
URBAN DESIGN
Ironworks at Pencoyd Landing
“Rich in texture and space, this urban design project successfully blurs the line between old and new, public and private, rustic and raw.”
ADAPTIVE REUSE
“An unapologetic celebration of materials—raw industrial materials, timber, masonry, and stone—that are tied seamlessly throughout the new public and private spaces with abundant natural daylight.”
LANDSCAPE
Arjay Miller Arboretum North Pond at Ford World Headquarters
“This is the type of landscape project that is not looking for formal fireworks or ostentatious originality but defines—with controlled design ambitions—a sensitive and intelligent approach to a ubiquitous problem: the mowed-lawn-next-to-highway landscape.””
INFRASTRUCTURE
Harvard University District Energy Facility
“Often the architecture of infrastructure is at best an afterthought. This amazing District Energy Facility shows us both how and why design is essential to a livable environment.”
Providence River Pedestrian Bridge
FACADES
Nancy and Rich Kinder Museum Building at the Museum of Fine Arts Houston
“The museum is a vessel of light—it contains and embodies the light of the day, amplifying the lyrical joining of art, place, and architecture. The facades capture and hold this ever-changing light. In the blink of an eye what was shadow becomes light, radically altering your physical relationship to the work.””
YOUNG ARCHITECTS
“Nabi Boyd’s work is both precise and playful. The thoughtful approach to each project has a softness and ease with site while reimagining the terms of context and material.”
GREEN BUILDING
Harvard University Science and Engineering Complex
Ford Calumet Environmental Center
CULTURAL
Nancy and Rich Kinder Museum Building at the Museum of Fine Arts Houston
Taipei Music Center, Performance Hall
Coca-Cola Stage at the Alliance Theatre
EXHIBITION DESIGN
Chicago Comics: 1960s to Now
“The displays reinforce the curatorial themes and beats, making fresh a graphic medium all but eclipsed by the cinematic success of its most tedious franchises.”
Linée Occulte: Drawing Architecture
TEMPORARY INSTALLATION
“The project has a beautifully eerie presence that seems to operate both on the level of visceral experience and conceptual clarity.”
RESIDENTIAL—SINGLE-UNIT
“This project offers both a compelling conceptual study in reassembled domestic organization and a set of thoughtful, cozy, real-life spaces.”
RESIDENTIAL—MULTIUNIT
Interior—Residential
RESIDENTIAL—MIXED USE
“Plenty of tower projects pay lip service to addressing human and metropolitan scales without getting either right. This one seems to find the balance between big-city verticality and the comforts of home.”
MIT Site 4
Cambridge, Massachusetts
RESTORATION & PRESERVATION
Grand Théâtre de Québec
Hall of State at Fair Park
BUILDING RENOVATION
Harvard Divinity School, Swartz Hall
INTERIOR—RETAIL
Knoll D.C. Showroom & Offices
“Balance is not the first thing about showrooms that comes to mind. Too often, these exhibition spaces bow to the pressures of saleability or, conversely, the consumer’s self-perception. ARO’s D.C. showroom gets its exactly right.”
COMMERCIAL—OFFICE
Baylor Scott & White Health Administrative Center
“This is a big building, but it feels approachable and workable thanks to generous views and sunlight.”
INTERIOR—OFFICE
INSTITUTIONAL—LIBRARIES
Stavros Niarchos Foundation Library
Adams Street Branch Library
INTERIOR—INSTITUTIONAL
Tecnológico de Monterrey Rectoria Building
INSTITUTIONAL—HIGHER ED
Cohen Quad, Exeter College
Morgan State University Calvin & Tina Tyler Hall
University of Pennsylvania Meeting & Guesthouse
INSTITUTIONAL—RELIGIOUS
“The playful, wonky massing admirably undercuts the severity of the revivalist architecture of its neighbor. But the best bits are to be found inside.”
St. Joseph’s University Arrupe Hall
INSTITUTIONAL—KINDERGARTENS, PRIMARY & HIGH SCHOOLS
Home Building at Thaden School
“The Home Building at Taden School responds excellently to its context, and what a context: a Marlon Blackwell campus and nearby in the Ozarks the beautiful work of Fay Jones. The roof echoes the morphing sheds of Blackwell’s buildings, while the wooden slats on the facade and in the ceiling of the great hall recall Jones’s Thorncrown Chapel—a truly elevated rural vernacular.”
City Kids Educational Center
COMMERCIAL—SPORTS & STADIUMS
INTERIOR—HOSPITALITY
“Anchored by a spectacularly elegant stair surrounded by columnar supports that descend from a sculpted ceiling, the Waterline Club interior is a splendid display of design.”
COMMERCIAL—HOSPITALITY (RESTAURANTS & BARS, HOTELS, RESORTS)
“The vaulted forms, material detail, and framed views make this a stellar architectural proposal.”
HEALTHCARE
The City of Hope Medical and Administrative Leadership Pavilion
“A laudatory solution to a tricky problem. The second-floor terrace and exposed circulation on the upper floors are particularly inspired.”
Michigan Animal Rescue League
INTERIOR—HEALTHCARE
Lawrence J. Ellison Institute for Transformative Medicine of USC
ARCHITECTURAL LIGHTING—OUTDOOR
Dwight D. Eisenhower Memorial
“The memorial, whose scheme appears slightly ponderous by day, really comes alive at night, thanks to the lighting design.”
ARCHITECTURAL LIGHTING—INDOOR
“Masterful lighting that successfully accentuates program and space, both inside and out.”
RESEARCH
“The vaulted forms, material detail, and framed views make this a stellar architectural proposal.”
STUDENT WORK—GROUP
“Although simple in their design, this house and accompanying ADU provided students with an excellent, mostly unparalleled opportunity. Not only did they engage with matters of construction, but also of zoning and sustainability.”
STUDENT WORK—INDIVIDUAL
“[It shows] a way other than depression and anxiety to engage with the more terrifying aspects of the Anthropocene.”
UNBUILT—EDUCATION
University of Manitoba Desautels Concert Hall
“One of the great challenges of making theater buildings good neighbors is finding ways to wrap the program with an architectural expression that doesn’t overwhelm the surroundings with looming blank walls. This project does that admirably—the curved entryway and shifting planes of the envelope come together to create an eminently approachable and seductive building.”
University of Chicago Center in Paris
The Chapel of St. Ignatius and the Gayle & Tom Benson Jesuit Center
UNBUILT—GREEN BUILDING
Honeybee Discovery Center
Brooklyn Mass Timber House
UNBUILT—RESIDENTIAL
“An endearing riff on the Chicago School, but form aside, the project’s underlying premise—to supply truly affordable housing in the heart of the Loop—deserves special attention.”
UNBUILT—CULTURAL
“Stark vertical geometries are a highlight of this very pink project, where the interior and exterior color palette provide a pleasant contrast with the natural scenery.”
Princeton University Art Museum
UNBUILT—PUBLIC
Inhale, Exhale, Sag, Flex
“It’s impressive how this outré proposal conjures so many distinct atmospheres with so few materials. Whatever its eccentricities (the designer details the use of “water bladders”), the project is a serious exploration in the life cycle of a building.”
UNBUILT—COMMERCIAL
UNBUILT—LANDSCAPE
Brisbane Baylands Master Plan
UNBUILT—MASTER PLAN
“This study should be commended for its forward-thinking approach toward coastline development. One can imagine this scheme being repurposed as an affordable housing prototype.”
UNBUILT—URBAN DESIGN
“Projects that dare to think beyond lot lines and that are willing to take on larger urban issues, codes and regulation, often sound a bit utopian or fantastical. On the contrary, ODA’s Beyond the Street brings a strong proposal to the table, backed up by a meticulous production and smart communication.”
Markham Square Housing District